Here's the text of President Obama's "high stakes" health care, er, insurance, er, whatever the fuck it is today reform speech that was delivered last night.
Having had the chance to read it over carefully, I find one overriding - and striking - aspect to the speech:
Barack Obama has learned nothing from any of the events of August.
And when I say nothing, I mean nothing. That speech could have been written in the last week of July and put on a shelf. It's as though the townhall rebellions never happened. It fails to acknowledge any of the realities that were manifest on September 8, 2009.
First, Obama did not provide a detailed vision of what he must have in the health care, er, insurance, er, whatever the fuck it is today reform legislation when it comes to his desk. Not a single hint of any willingness to lead. Again. It is now September 9, 2009 and we still have no idea what health care, er, insurance, er, whatever the fuck it is today reform actually is. Neither does Congress.
Second, Obama stuck to the laughable proposition that the public option is still in play. Oh sure, the President's flaks will claim that is only to keep it on the table for a bargaining chip, but the fact of the matter is this: You can't bargain with something that doesn't exist. Opponents of the public option aren't going to give anything away because they don't have to. It's dead. By leaving it on the table, Obama has only ensured that there will be a prolonged and messy fight over the issue in the House.
Third, Obama offered nothing new to dampen public skepticism of reform. He assurances were over generalized, bland and fully of weasel words. If citizens expected to come away with answers to their criticisms, they were most likely disappointed. Again, Obama focuses on dismissing any or all criticism as either uninformed or politically motivated.
Fourth, again... No mention of how this shit gets paid for. The whole "we can save money by enacting this reform" has failed the Laugh Test since Day One. And polling suggests this is a major concern for voters. But answering that concern would involve some tough choices. So, instead of offering something concrete, Obama continues to pretend that the financing of reform is some sort of minor detail that can be attended to later.
I could go on, but you get the picture.
I've said it before and I'll say it again: Barack Obama, for all his super-geniusness, is one of the most rigid, blinkered and unimaginative souls I've ever seen in high office. The range of his mighty intellect runs the gamut from A to B. That he would offer up a July speech in September simply highlights that fact.